Edinburgh 2011 N-Z


Naïve Dance Masterclass, C eca. This gleefully absurd, neat little dance spoof raises plenty of smiles. Baffling, but certainly amusing. 3/5
Nathan Penlington: Uri And Me, Underbelly. A lightly thought-provoking show, full of absurd and surprising quirks. Needs straightening. 3/5
The One Man Show, C venues. Odd collection of musings on acting that entertain but fail to gel. Beautiful visuals make up for it. 3/5
One Under, Pleasance Courtyard. A smart young ensemble, brimming with acting talent, present stories of love and loneliness in the city. 3/5
Opposition, Zoo Southside. A madcap medley of poetry, delivered with gusto and skill, turns our leaders' political language on its head. 3/5
Othello, Zoo Roxy. A competent but pedestrian Shakespearean production. Neither the ingenuity nor the class to justify the ticket price. 2/5 
The Oxford Revue, Underbelly.Ticks off every student sketch comedy stereotype. Some laughs, but full of cheap gags and lazy references. 2/5
Oyster Eyes, Just The Tonic. Inventive. Bananas. Very, very funny. The most original sketch group at the Fringe is also one of the best. 4/5
Parallel Memories, C. Two excellent dancers explore something unclear skillfully. Lovely on the eyes, mushy on the brain. 3/5
Penny Dreadful's Etherdome, Assembly. Gleaming eyes and manic laughs from performers and audience alike. Crowd-pleasing, knockout stuff. 4/5
The Perils of Love and Gravity, Bedlam. Moments of genius flicker, but a flabby script blunts the obvious talent of this creative team. 2/5
Recursion, C Soco. A play about memory loss. I can't wait to forget it. 1/5
Remember This, Bedlam. A couple of touching moments can't quite save a script that's predictable and a little dull. 2/5.
Release, Pleasance Dome. A sage look at criminal justice. Blisteringly relevant work, complete with fiery, heartfelt performances. 4/5
Rich Hall's Hoe Down, Pleasance Courtyard. Hall and his band make for great late night company. Top country music, and a bar onstage! 3/5
Roar, C. A thin, disagreeable narrative clashes with a gleeful, pantomime aesthetic; this ambitious piece can't quite decide what it is. 2/5
Robin Ince, Buff’s Club. Intimate free-flowing angry comedy. Proof that ultra-leftist fury can still be funny in the age of McIntyre. 4/5
Rockertinkler, Zoo. Good-humoured play covering everything from nudism to philosophy. At times breadth became isolating, but well acted. 3/5
Scary Gorgeous, Bedlam. Aptly titled, this white-knuckle show is rarely less than brilliant. A beautiful rollercoaster of brave choices. 4/5
The Seagull Effect, Zoo Roxy. Ambitious in scope, if a little literal-minded, this highly visual piece is filled with little delights. 3/5
The Set List, Tron. Improv with inherently flawed format. Stand-ups struggle to work list of phrases into set. Weak compere didn't help. 2/5
Shane & Eddie, Just The Tonic. Imagine two peppy dads from a village panto being given their own show. Bad impressions of rich people. 2/5
Shlomo, Underbelly. Absurdly talented beatboxer gives a jaw dropping performance that must be seen to be believed. Fun as they come. 4/5
Shutterland, Zoo. Dynamic physical performances in a chilling tale of one man against the system. Could have pushed the staging further. 3/5
SNAP.CATCH.SLAM, Pleasance Courtyard. Too much feeling and not enough telling in these three disparate monologues. Slick, not stirring. 2/5
Sold, Pleasance Courtyard. A moving and exceptionally well executed piece of drama carrying an important message. Top performances. 4/5.
Sophie Alderson, Voodoo Rooms. A likable performer with some strong ideas, but the gag rate is far too low. 2/5
Steal Compass.., Zoo Southside. A brilliantly astute dissection of modern fatherhood; solo performer Rachel Blackman is a fierce talent. 4/5 
Story Shakespeare: Love's Labours Lost, C too. A warm, finely honed adaptation, with some terrific left-field gags and enchanting songs. 4/5 
Street Dreams, Underbelly. Refreshingly imaginative and assuredly performed, this lightly comic debut pulls all the right strings. 4/5
The Table, Pleasance Dome. Not strictly a play and not entirely puppetry, rather a delightful medley of visual ideas. Mesmerising. 4/5
Thirsty, Pleasance Courtyard. Precise and poignant, violent, daring and vulnerable: this is keen, rocket-fuelled performance. Strap in. 4/5
Thom Tuck, Pleasance Dome. Bizarrely uneven, but critically funny observations and a risky throughline delight and engage. Ambitious. 3/5
Tim Key, Pleasance. Superlative stand-up from a man who loves baths so much he's got one on stage. Deep breath: prepare to belly laugh. 5/5
Timothy, Bedlam. Rambling where it should be neat, this Hitchcock-lite needs sharpening before it really thrills. Domestic. 2/5
Toby, Pleasance Courtyard. Superbly characterised comedy duo, with wonderful onstage tension. Comedy interspersed with subtle theatrics. 4/5
The Toll, C Soco. Well crafted characters and snappy dialogue ensure an enjoyable hour of new writing. Fun staging too. 3/5
Tomboy Blues, Zoo Southside. Warm and well-observed exploration of gender by two hyper-charming performers. Original, if a little wordy. 3/5
Tonight, Sandy Grierson Will..., Assembly. Astounding, electric - the performance is a protean feat, and the script will sweep you away. 5/5
Uncle Tom: Deconstructed, Space 45. A brave interrogation of the legacy of slavery. Skillfully performed and heart-wrenchingly thorough. 5/5
Vertigo, Bedlam. A tiny show with a massive heart, performed with the lightest of touches. This gem is for anyone who has ever grown up. 4/5
Viewless, Remarkable Arts. An intriguing, unsettling and at times hilarious exploration of a mundane job that literally changes lives. 3/5
Vikki Stone, Gilded Balloon. She might have a sweet smile and rosy demeanour, but Stone's comic songs are wonderfully filthy. 3/5
Waiting For Alice, Pleasance Courtyard. Witty script, superb acting, beautiful set - a brilliantly original take on Alice in Wonderland. 4/5
Waterproof, Pleasance Dome. Overflowing with promise, but a confused narrative and limp visual tricks disappoint. A damp squib. 2/5
Wil Hodgson, The Stand. An engaging storyteller who makes cracking company for an hour. Often funny, always entertaining. 3/5
Within Range, Zoo Southside. A bold dance concept, and yet overly cerebral choreography and heavy-handed symbolism fail to enthrall. 2/5
WitTank, Just The Tonic. Accessible, well-rounded sketch comedy. Friendly, easy to grasp premises, at times spectacularly pulled-off. 4/5
The World Holds Everyone Apart..., Underbelly. A dull narrative, no visuals and a confusing performance leaves you unaffected. Lacking. 2/5
Wrens, Sweet Grassmarket. Plenty of claustrophobia in the detailed set, and a few good turns, but this wartime drama quickly wears thin. 2/5
Wright Brothers, Pleasance Courtyard. Pleasant enough and occasionally charming, but this aviator bio never really takes flight. 2/5
You Will Be Rare, Zoo. By turns worrying and endearing, this bonkers sales pitch will transform your world. Infectious. #cash4ramman 4/5
Your Last Breath, Pleasance Dome. Searingly complex, literate and invigorating - an adrenaline shot to the mind and the heart. Terrific. 5/5