Edinburgh 2011 A-M


The Adventures of Alvin Sputnik, Underbelly. Hilarious and tearjerking, this puppet show will melt the coldest of hearts. A must see. 5/5
The Adventures of Wound Man..., Pleasance Courtyard. Chris Goode enchants with this quirky, tender and frequently side-splitting tale. 4/5
Agnes & Walter, Zoo Southside. A glorious dance eulogy to the idea of growing old with someone. Free-spirited, life-affirming new work. 5/5
Aisle 16 R Kool, FF Banshee's Labyrinth. See the three best poets of the Fringe, as they work best: in a dungeon, for free. Real cool. 4/5
The Alchemystorium, Bedlam. A dazzling tour-de-force of puppetry and mime that is as side-splittingly funny as it is achingly touching. 5/5
Alex Horne, Pleasance Dome. Wildly inventive and very funny, Horne pulls off his ambitious concept with considerable aplomb. 4/5
Alma Mater, St George's West. Innovative use of an iPad in this atmospheric installation. Creepy and lovely in equal bursts. 3/5.
Alphonse, Pleasance Courtyard. A generous paean to the imagination, this simple, fluid story is told effortlessly well. Easy viewing. 3/5
And The Birds Fell From The Sky, C eca. Totally immersive and genuinely powerful, this video-goggle piece is as original as they come. 4/5 
Around the World in 80 Quid, Pleasance Courtyard. Funny, intoxicating storytelling from a musical vagrant. A hedonistic twist of genres. 3/5 
Asher Treleaven, Pleasance Courtyard. Ingenious, highly original set. Socially responsible rhetoric + cock jokes = a winning formula. 4/5 
Bane Trilogy, Pleasance Dome. Bane keeps raising the bar for solo performance, and its gag rate takes no prisoners. Totally magnificent. 5/5
Bepo & Co, C. Youngsters in greasepaint shout their way through a frustratingly unintelligible play. You've probably seen it before. 2/5 
Body Of Water, Pleasance Courtyard. Anarchic squat drama with a nicely eked out story, but the flat staging and substance of a TV drama. 3/5
The Boom Jennies, Pleasance Courtyard. The constant dancing & physical gags became samey or lost purpose, although they worked for some. 2/5
Bluebeard, Underbelly. A famously horrible story re-told with irony and a bag of tricks, but sadly lacking in humour or heart. 2/5 
Body of Water, Pleasance Courtyard. A cool play with an even cooler soundtrack. Riots, raves and drugs. Skilful, slick and savvy. 3/5 
Bones, Zoo. A strong script and a photorealistic performance are constrained by a lack of variety and tone in this chilling monologue. 3/5
Broken Wing, Venue 13. A crowded set muddles a simple story; some winning cultural observations can't make up for a lack of depth. Fair. 2/5
Cabaret Whore, Underbelly. Four eccentric stars for the price of one silken-voiced Sarah-Louise Young. Guaranteed to get you guffawing. 4/5
The Caroline Carter Show, Zoo. Pleasant if unexciting. An irresistibly likeable Carter becomes much funnier as the whiskey goes round! 2/5
Choose Death, Just The Tonic. An inspired set of disturbing characters in this dark comedy. At points repetitive, but enjoyable overall. 3/5
Christmas For Two, Just The Tonic. Promising female duo have hilarious comic presence and strong characters, but some skits need a trim. 3/5
Clockheart Boy, C. With its slick performances and gentle treatment of loss, this is a very special fable, and a slick little treasure. 4/5
Comedy Zone, Pleasance Courtyard. A perfectly chosen variety box of impressive stand ups. Each very different, each totally hilarious. 5/5
Dead Cat Bounce, Pleasance Courtyard. Enjoyable as ever with some good new songs, but old material shines brightest. 3/5
Death Song, Udderbelly. Inspired stagecraft, impassioned performance work and a unique aesthetic, punctured only by an imperfect plot. 3/5
Devil In The Detail, Zoo Roxy. A comedy that 8-year-olds might enjoy - but marketed at adults and bearing a 12+ rating. Unfortunate. 2/5
Doris Day Can Fuck Off, Zoo Southside. Behind its barmy facade, this challenging show is packed with insight. Provocative and uplifting. 4/5
Dr Brown, Underbelly. Mr Bean and Andy Kaufman's love child has made a show, and it/he is mental/genius. Sell your money for a ticket. 5/5
Dream Pill, Underbelly. Carefully directed, bravely performed, this short issue-based play balances charms and chills. Bracing. 4/5
Dry Ice, Underbelly. Poetic monologue on life in a strip club. Each rapid-fire rhyme hits its target; don't miss this. 4/5 
The Ducks, Pleasance Courtyard. The stakes seem high but we have absolutely no idea why in this morbidly confusing little thriller. 2/5
Edward Aczel, Underbelly. Aczel remains the definitive anti-comedian. Terrible comedy, beautifully executed. Very funny. 4/5
The End, Pleasance Courtyard. Hypnotic and poignant, this rewardingly dense piece tugs at both your brain stem and your heart strings. 4/5
Eric Lampaert, Pleasance Courtyard. Autobiographical comedy with more self-commentary than story, but that's part of the charm. Warming. 4/5 
Flirt Fiction, Space North Bridge. Like a Marmite dildo - not to everyone's taste. Vulgar, misdirected, although oddly pleasurable. 2/5
Forgetting Natasha, Zoo Southside. Pretty spectacular projection is dampened by comfortable dance and an earnest, unnecessary script. 3/5
Free Time Radical, Pleasance Courtyard. Great ideas and impressive design are unbalanced by an awkward narrative. Doesn't hold water. 2/5
Frimston and Rowett, Just The Tonic (Store). Herculean punning lifts a few sketches, but most fail to take off. Needs some sharpening. 2/5
Gagtanamo Bay, Royal Mile Tavern. Unique, hilarious and best of all, free. A blinding hidden treasure that subverts expectations. 5/5
Grisly Tales From Tumblewater, Pleasance Courtyard. Dickens meets Dahl in this lovingly written, nimbly performed adaptation. Flies by! 3/5
Guilt & Shame, Just The Tonic. For 'depraved comedy' this is far cleverer than the title suggests. Hilarious, if not inspired. 4/5
Heavy Like the Weight of a Flame, Underbelly. A noble idea doesn't redeem this over-long, over-complicated and over-acted solo show. 1/5
Hit Comet, Bedlam. 'Dunk your heart in the dipping sauce of my love.' Head to this comic take on the pop industry for the lyrics alone! 3/5
Humphrey Ker, Pleasance Courtyard. Ker charms as a storyteller and impresses as a writer with this persistently funny Boys' Own parody. 3/5
I Hope My Heart Goes First, St George's West. Strong performances all round from a scarily young company, but show needs more insight. 3/5.
Ian D Montford - Spirit Comedium, Pleasance Courtyard. Phoney psychic attempts to entertain with three tricks - and even fewer jokes. 2/5
In The Dust, Zoo Southside. Fierce choreography and impressive physical feats, but there's an absence of heart in this dance triptych. 3/5
John Peel's Shed, Underbelly. Unique and sincere, this beautifully observed hour will leave you emboldened and enraptured. Affirming. 5/5
Josie Long, Pleasance Dome. Ever heartfelt, ever intelligent comedy from the Fringe's loveliest stand-up. You'll wish she was family. 3/5
Idiots of Ants, Pleasance Courtyard.Don't break any comedy boundaries, but by George these boys can work a crowd. Slick as they come. 4/5.
The Improverts, Bedlam. Improv on hyperdrive - wired performers and a consistently up-for-it crowd make for a cracking late-night treat. 4/5
The Infant, Pleasance Courtyard. A little too ambiguous, but the high-octane performances keep this creepy play suspenseful and slick. 3/5
The Investigation, Zoo Southside. Committed performances, but the physical and musical accompaniment woefully overeggs the pudding. 2/5
Kalagora, Zoo Roxy. Rich-voiced Bose is a charismatic performer - unfortunately his poetry is packed full of jarringly empty metaphors. 2/5 
La Putyka, Zoo Southside. A visual treat: inventive and acrobatic clowns, plus some seriously sexy trampolining. Needs pulling together. 3/5
Late Night Gimp Fight, Pleasance Courtyard. All-male sketch troupe, too many wanking jokes. Very little in the way of funny or clever. 2/5
Leeds Tealights, Just the Tonic. Traditional sketch comedy at its finest, and an impressively high gag rate to boot. Goes down a treat. 4/5
Lights. Camera. Improvise!, C venues. Improvising a complete and hilarious movie every day that always raises the roof. 4/5
Little Matter, Bedlam. This weird, adventurous fairytale will propel you to another time and place: a unique and unmissable experience. 5/5
Love Songs For A Timewaster, Gilded Balloon. An uninspiring story sung with mixed metaphors aplenty. It would baffle if it didn't bore. 1/5
Mark Olver, Just The Tonic. A dark narrative runs nicely alongside traditional stand up. Likable and often very funny. 3/5
Matt Tiller, Just The Tonic. Like watching a caught fish flap impotently on the deck, before, at last, its eyes glaze over, and it dies. 1/5
Moon Horse and the Mars Men From Jupiter, FF Buffs Club. Impossible to dislike for its amateurish, free-spirited optimism. Catchy songs! 3/5
Morgan and West, Gilded Balloon. The genial pair pull some neat mind-reading and Victorian banter into a cohesive, family-friendly hour. 4/5
Movin' Melvin Brown, C. Friendly evening with a music legend who has plenty of stories to tell. Most of which are pretty titillating. 3/5
Muscle, Zoo Roxy. Moving and neatly layered exploration of men and manliness. Bursting with strong solo work and tight ensemble scenes. 4/5
My Big Gay Italian Wedding, C. Not for everybody, but as fun as they come. Camp, raunchy slapstick with an exceedingly warm heart. 4/5